Web Analytics Made Easy - Statcounter
Author: topstuf
Date: February 13, 2019

Best Waterproof Eyeliner - Top Reviews and Buying Guide

Eyeliner is an integral part of any modern makeup style. These products come in different styles, colors, and shapes and finding the one that is ideal for you might not seem like an easy task upon first glance. To help you navigate this market, we will delve into the characteristics of eyeliners and we will help you identify the best waterproof eyeliner in 2020.

 What you should keep in mind when you are looking for the best waterproof eyeliner

If you want to make sure that you are buying a product that is worth your money, you need to take the time to learn as much as possible about waterproof eyeliners. These products are quite simple so the process should be quick and enjoyable. Below is a brief look at some of the main factors that you should consider when you are trying to find the best waterproof eyeliner on the market today.

Type of eyeliners

This is the first thing that you should be aware of when you are in the market for a new waterproof earlier. As we have stated earlier, these products come in different types, with each one having its own set benefits and serving a specific purpose. The most common types are pencil eyeliners, gel eyeliners, liquid, and matte eyeliners.


Before buying the eyeliner, you need to check the color options that are available to you. Not all shades are ideal for every person. This is mostly due to the wide variations in eye shape, color, and skin tone of the area around the eyes. Generally speaking, neutral colors are considered the ideal choice because their subtle texture allows them to easily blend in a wide range of situations, both casual and professional.

Waterproof properties

While many brands like to advertise their products as fully waterproof, few are can actually provide complete protection from water. Waterproof eyeliners need to be long-lasting, smudge proof and should be able to block water from entering into the lids. Since taking the product description at face value can be seen as an unreliable approach, the best way to go about verifying this is reading customer reviews. This will give you an in-depth look at what to expect with regard to the waterproof properties of the eyeliner.

Organic formula

Eyeliners that are made using a lot of strong chemicals are likely to cause a host of issues ranging from rashes and irritations to strong allergic reactions. If you want to avoid this, you need to make sure that your eyeliner is entirely formulated from organic ingredients. Before making a purchase decision, check the list of ingredients in the product description.


The formula is not the only thing that determines the overall quality of the eyeliner. As a matter of fact, the durability of the pencil is just as important. In the case of gel lines, the same applies to the dedicated brush. It should be made using high-quality materials so that it can handle prolonged and extensive use.

The price

The main thing that you should know about the price is that it is not always an accurate indicator of quality. Several brands tend to inflate their prices in a way that is completely disconnected from the actual value of the product.  Instead of letting the price of the eyeliner sway you, focus on the characteristic of the product itself and the reviews left by customers who bought the product.

Ease of application and removal

This factor is extremely crucial if you value convenience and practicality. Good eyeliners should be easy to apply and their removal process should be effortless. This quality is especially valuable if you want to use your eyeliner on a daily basis.


Testing products on animals have long been one of the darkest secrets of the skin care industry. While the number of companies that conduct this kind of testing continues to decrease with each passing years, there are still some brands that uphold these unfortunate practices. If you value animal rights, then you should make sure that any product you get is certified cruelty-free.

Frequently asked questions

1 – Which type of eyeliner is the best?

The answer to this question depends on what you are looking for in eyeliners. With that being said, our two preferred options are liquid eyeliners and pencil eyeliners. Liquid eyeliners are virtually peerless when it comes to crafting sharp line and intense effects whereas pencil eyeliners are easier to control and are generally more accurate than other types. Furthermore, pencil eyeliners tend to be significantly cheaper.

2 – Are liquid eyeliners easy to remove?

Removing liquid eyeliners requires a little bit more effort compared to other types of eyeliner. However, as long as you get a high-quality product, the process should still be relatively quick and easy. The best way to remove liquid eyeliners is by using special makeup remover or a regular moisturizer.

3 – Is it possible to fix liquid eyeliner mistakes?

There is no reason why you should not be able to fix a makeup mishap. In fact, it is remarkably easy. Just dip a cotton swab into a makeup remover and maneuver it around the area of the mistake until you get the desired result. This should be done in a slow and careful manner as the eye makeup remover should not come into contact with your eyes.  An even safer and more practical method is to use a dedicated makeup remover pen that is specifically designed to correct these mistakes.

Top 5 best waterproof eyeliner in 2020

1 - L'Oréal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner

L'Oreal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner, Blackest Black (Packaging May Vary)
2,492 Reviews
L'Oreal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner, Blackest Black (Packaging May Vary)
  • Infallible Lacquer Gel Eyeliner: A glossy, lacquered eye is now easier than ever to...
  • L'Oreal Eyeliner: Use our best eyeliners to achieve an everyday eye look or a bold cat eye...
  • Create you perfect eye makeup look with our collection of mascaras, achieve sleek lines...
  • Because You're Worth It: L'Oréal Paris helps you create the look you want with our full...

The L’Oréal Lacquer boasts a number of qualities that make it a strong contender for the title of best waterproof eyeliner on the market. It offers a wide selection of eye-catching colors and comes in a comprehensive package that includes a dedicated flat brush. On top of being very light and easy to apply, the effect that is produced by this eyeliner is simply exquisite and the intense shine that it gives you will not go unnoticed by those around you.

One of the most impressive aspects of this eyeliner is just how long it lasts. It retains much of its consistency for up to 24 hours and you can even leave it on before you sleep only to find it relatively intact the next day. This is mostly due to the texture of the gel itself. It has a creamy and matte composition that lends itself to more resilience upon application.

Ease of application and consistency are not the only thing that set this eyeliner apart from other alternatives in its price range. Its best characteristic is probably its remarkable ability to accentuate the outline of the eyes regardless of their shape or size. This makes the L’Oréal Paris Lacquer an ideal option for a wide range of people.

The pros

  • The shine that it gives you is quite intense
  • The eyeliner is very easy to apply and remove
  • The smooth and creamy texture makes for an enjoyable wearing
  • It goes well with any shape of eyes
  • It can remain consistent for up to 24 hours after the initial application
  • The price is highly affordable

The cons

  • The eyeliner takes a relatively long time to dry
  • The design of the brush is somewhat underwhelming

2- Vassoul Winged Eyeliner Stamp

Vassoul Winged Eyeliner Stamp, 2 double-sided pens, 1 Left and 1 right, Wing Stamp with Eyeliner...
45 Reviews
Vassoul Winged Eyeliner Stamp, 2 double-sided pens, 1 Left and 1 right, Wing Stamp with Eyeliner...
  • NO MORE WINGING IT - The Winged Eyeliner Stamp will literally be your dream. Line up the...
  • EYE-SPECIFIC STAMPS - Each stamp was specifically designed to suit each individual eye...
  • SMUDGE-PROOF & WATER-RESISTANT - The formula is long-lasting, waterproof and smudge-proof....
  • DOUBLE-SIDED PENS ¨C Each pen has 2 ends. One end for stamping and the other has a very...

The Vassoul Winged Stamp brings a lot of convenience and practicality to the user. This battery-powered eyeliner comes with a well-designed pair of pens that are specifically tailored to the corner of your eyes. This makes applying the eyeliner an extremely easy and enjoyable process. Moreover, the application can be completed in just a few seconds, which is ideal if you are planning on using the eyeliner on a daily basis and can’t afford to spend a lot of time on a long makeup routine. Considering the relatively low price, you are getting a lot of value with this unit.

The eyeliner has a lot going for it with regard to its overall effectiveness and consistency. On top of being waterproof and smudge proof, it is entirely made from highly potent and fully organic ingredients that ensure a natural-looking shine. Thanks to the candellila wax and camauba wax combo, this eyeliner dries up much quicker than the competition. More importantly, the organic composition of this eyeliner ensures that it won’t cause any of the rashes, irritations, or strong allergic reactions that are often triggered by some of the added chemicals that are found in some other products.

The pros

  • The organic formula of the eyeliner makes for a safe use
  • It dries up very quickly thanks to a mixture of candellila wax and camauba wax
  • The pens that are included in the package are very well designed
  • It is waterproof and smudge proof
  • The price to quality ratio is great
  • It only takes a few seconds to apply the eyeliner

The cons

  • The battery is not as durable as we would have liked
  • The amount of liquid that comes with the pen is fairly low

3 - stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

When it comes to beauty and personal care products, few brands can match stila in term of consistent quality and overall reliability. The Stay All Day waterproof liquid eyeliner allows you to create a plethora of beautiful effects that are as exquisite as they are precise. This ranges from very thin lines to dramatic, prominent patterns that are guaranteed to catch the eye of everyone around you. More impressively, this eyeliner is easy to apply and even novice users will find the process of applying it to be smooth and enjoyable.

The liquid that comes in the pen is formulated in a way that enables it to remain consistent and perfectly lined throughout the day. In addition to this, the absence of any extra chemicals ensures that this product is completely safe for people who are prone to developing skin irritations and experiences allergic reactions. As for the colors, you have the option of picking between 14 colors that cover the full scope of preferences and tastes. Some of the other qualities that are worth noting include the remarkable quick-drying properties of the eyeliner as well as the simplicity of the removal process.

The pros

  • The eyeliner can stay on for a whole day after the initial application
  • The application process is very smooth and simple
  • The coverage that it provides is quite decent
  • It boasts several quick-drying properties
  • It is easy to remove
  • The organic formula of the liquid makes it safe for people with allergies

The cons

  • The unit seems to dry out after a couple months of use
  • The quality to price ratio is underwhelming compared to other similar products

4 - Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner

Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner, Onyx, 2 COUNT
7,795 Reviews
Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner, Onyx, 2 COUNT
  • Smudge Resistant Pencil Eyeliner: With a self sharpening tip and a smudge resistant,...
  • Define Your Eye: No eye look is complete without Maybelline Eyeliner amp up the drama with...
  • Maybelline Is The Eye Expert: Whatever your signature eye look, whether natural or...
  • Maybelline has what you need to create any look: foundation, bb creams, concealers and...

This mechanical eyeliner comes from one of the more established brands in the space. Like all Maybelline products, it is feature-rich and highly stylish. The Unstoppable Eyeliner features a practical self-sharpening and it is capable of crafting concise and natural-looking lines that appear to be made by a makeup professional. The color options are not too shabby either as you have the possibility of opting for a soothing blue or green eyeliner, a rugged black one, or a softer unassuming brown color that goes well with any style.

The subtle touch that this eyeliner delivers is without a doubt its strongest suit. Unlike many other products on the market, the patterns that you create with the Maybelline have a natural quality to them that is generally hard to replicate. Moreover, it helps you create a perfect canvas that goes well with any type of foundation, bb cream, or concealer. Ease of application is another quality that is worth praising as the process can be competed in just a few seconds. The removal of the eyeliner is just as easy and only requires you to wash it away using Gamier Micellar water.

The pros

  • The patterns that you can create with this unit are accurate and clean
  • The automatic sharpening makes the eyeliner extremely precise
  • The colors are quite exquisite and eye-catching
  • The gel is highly efficient and dries up fairly quickly
  • It goes really well with any type of foundations or bb creams
  • Applying and removing the eyeliner is remarkably simple and straightforward

The cons

  • The eyeliner is not entirely smudge proof
  • More color options would have been nicer

5 - Docolor Liquid Eyeliner Pen Waterproof Smudge-proof Fast Dry Eye Makeup Gel

The last option in our list is also the most affordable one. For such a cheap unit, the Docolor offers a lot of great features that are geared toward making everything more convenient and simple for you. The pen is characterized by a very soft tip that ensures a smooth liquid flow at all times while eliminating any sort of skipping, smudging, or pulling. Additionally, the liquid is highly consistent and tends to dry as soon as it is applied.

The patterns that you can produce with this cheap eyeliner are quite impressive considering the price point. The glossy black color is sleek enough to fit a wide array of styles and the 12 hours wear eliminates the need for multiple reapplications throughout the day. On top of all of this, this eyeliner boasts several other qualities that are seldom seen at the entry-level range. A prime example of this is the fact that it is designed to accommodate people with sensitive eyes and those who wear contact lenses. Furthermore, it is extremely easy to remove since it only requires the use of warm water in order to be completely washed off.

The pros

  • This is one of the highest quality entry-level options
  • It provides a long-lasting wear that reaches 12 hours
  • The tip of the pen is very sharp and precise
  • The glossy black color of the eyeliner is quite sleek and stylish
  • It is an ideal option for people with sensitive eyes or contact lenses
  • The removal process is rather simple and only requires the use of warm water

The cons

  • The eyeliner pen does not seem to be durable enough to handle extensive use
  • Some users have found it to be a little bit too shiny

The verdict

The market offers a lot of options when it comes to eyeliners. The options that we reviewed here cover every single type of these products as well as every budget category. On top of being well-designed and completely waterproof, the eyeliners that we picked are all very sleek and will add an undeniable touch of style to your makeup. Go over each review and pick the one that fits your needs the most.

Last update on 2024-07-12 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Copyright © 2024 All Rights Reserved
 This site is a participant in the Amazon services LLC associates program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.