Web Analytics Made Easy - Statcounter
Author: topstuf
Date: February 13, 2019

Best eyeshadow palettes - Top Reviews and Buying Guide

There are several makeup products that can be effectively used to accentuate your eyes and make them stand out more. One such product is eyeshadow palettes. This simple and affordable solution offers a wide array of shade combinations that can help you create any look you desire. Whether you want a style that is suited for everyday use, casual hangouts, or late night parties, you are bound to find an eyeshadow palette that meets your requirements and accommodates your eye color. In this article, we will go over some of the main factors that you should consider when you are looking for the best eyeshadow palettes and we will review some of the best options that are available on the market today.

The factors that you should keep in mind when picking the best eyeshadow palettes

To make sure that you are getting an eyeshadow palette that suits you, you need to be aware of several variables before committing to a purchase. Below is a brief overview of the factors that you should prioritize.

Eye color

This is the first factor that you should consider when you are looking for an eyeshadow palette. Each eye color requires a specific set of shades that can accentuate its pigmentation and highlight it in an effective manner. Knowing which colors are complementary to each other will allow you to pick a product that can accommodate you.

The level of pigmentation

This is an extremely important factor that plays a significant role in determining whether or not a palette is worthy of your money.  For an eyeshadow to be effective in accentuating your eyes, the colors must have a high level of pigmentation that enables them to create intense visual effects. Products that lack this quality create a bland look and ultimately fail in highlighting your features.

Easy blending

Every great eyeshadow should be able to blend easily into the skin. This is essential for a smooth application process and it ensures that you are getting the most out of your palette. More importantly, makeup products that blend easily don’t leave any fallout after they are applied and are generally more long-wearing and consistent than the products that lack this quality.

Color options

The importance of this factor depends on what you are expecting out of your eyeshadow palette. If you have a specific color in mind and have a clear idea of the style that you want, then getting a palette with limited shade options is not an issue. On the other hand, if you are still undecided and want to try various colors and patterns, then you should opt for the eyeshadow palette that offers a comprehensive set of shades.

Organic ingredients

The area around your eyes is a relatively sensitive part of the face. This is why the formula of the product should only consist of naturally-sourced ingredients. The inclusion of harsh chemical components can cause a host of issues that range for mild rashes to strong allergic reactions and irritations.

The texture

Like any facial makeup product, the texture should be as light and smooth as possible. Besides the visual aspect, a product with good texture settles much more effectively into the skin and does not cause any discomfort regardless of how long you wear it. The best eyeshadow palettes are typically characterized by a creamy and seamless texture.


The skin care industry has long been criticized for testing its products on animals. Fortunately, this practice seems to be dying out as more established brands move toward less cruel and more sophisticated methods of testing. With that being said, there are still some companies that insist on conducting this sort of testing. If you don’t want your money to go to these brands, stick to products that are certified cruelty-free

The fragrance

As it is the case with most makeup products, the scent that is produced by eyeshadow palettes covers the full spectrum, ranging from barely detectable to absolutely unbearable. Some eye makeup products, in particular, are notorious for having a strong industrial smell. If you want to avoid them, check some customer feedback to see if there are any complaints about the scent.

The price

Eyeshadow palettes are some of the most affordable makeup products on the market. Most options are priced within the $10 to $20 range, and you can even find decent products for as low as $5. Even professional-grade options don’t command a price that is significantly higher than that. If a particular unit seems overpriced, it is more often than not a mark up by a retailer or a major brand.

The quality of the case

While this might not seem as important as some of the other factors discussed above, the case is still highly relevant to the quality and user experience that are offered by an eyeshadow palette. A product that is packaged in a sturdy and well-designed case is likely to last longer and will provide easier access to the shades.

Top 3 best eyeshadow palettes

1 - Beauty Glazed 63 Colors Eyeshadow Professional Makeup

Beauty Glazed 63 Colors Eyeshadow Professional Makeup 63 Colors EyeShadow Palette Powder With...
  • ✦ SUPER PIGMENTED, SOFT AND SMOOTH: Super creamy, velvety soft and smooth, easy to layer...
  • ✦ LONG LASTING COLOR: Stay on for all day. Highly pigmented and long lasting colors,...
  • ✦ 63 SHADES WITH POP COLORS: Create endless looks with 63 pop colors, cool and stunning....
  • ✦ MATTE AND SHIMMER COLORS: Both matte shadows as well as shimmers with creamy texture....

This comprehensive set offers professional-grade makeup at a very affordable price. It features 63 shades with pop colors and the effects that you can create using them are virtually endless. The level of pigmentation is exceptionally high and their soft and smooth texture allows them to settle into the skin in a quick and effective manner. Moreover, these products are consistent and long-wearing, lasting for up to 24 hours after the initial application without losing any of their shine.

On top of boasting some of the most vivid and eye-catching colors that we have ever reviewed, this palette’s delicate texture has no flying power, which is ideal for giving eye makeup the docile and unassuming look that everybody wants. It is also worth noting that eyeshadow does not contain any harsh chemicals, making it safe for use by people who have sensitive skin and prone to developing rashes and allergies.

In addition to the eyeshadow palette, the package also comes with a set of brushes and powder blender for more convenient application of your makeup. The packaging itself is quite sleek and features an exquisite gold lettering cover.

The pros

  • The value for the money that this set offers is remarkably high
  • The range of colors is very diverse and wide
  • The texture has no flying power
  • You can expect to wear eyeshadow for up to 24 hours
  • The packaging is very stylish and well put together
  • The lack of strong chemical ingredients makes this set ideal for people with sensitive skin

The cons

  • The makeup brushes feel somewhat flimsy and not of good quality
  • The shimmer shadows are not shinny enough

2 - Beauty Glazed Pigmented Matte and Shimmer 35 Colors Chunky Eyeshadow Palette

Beauty Glazed Eyeshadow Palette Matte Eyeshadow Pallet Pigmented Shades Makeup Palette Set Shimmer...
3,663 Reviews
Beauty Glazed Eyeshadow Palette Matte Eyeshadow Pallet Pigmented Shades Makeup Palette Set Shimmer...
  • ✦ SUPER PIGMENTED, SOFT AND SMOOTH: Super creamy, velvety soft and smooth, easy to layer...
  • ✦ LONG LASTING COLOR: Stay on for all day. Highly pigmented and long lasting colors,...
  • ✦ 35 SHADES WITH POP COLORS: Create endless looks with 35 pop colors, cool and stunning....
  • ✦ MATTE AND SHIMMER COLORS: Both matte shadows as well as shimmers with creamy texture....

This is one of the top-selling palettes on the market and for a good reason. Like the previous set, it comes in a stylish package with shiny gold lettering cover. It offers you 35 color options and boasts all the qualities that you would like to see in high-quality eye makeup products. The level of pigmentation is exceptional and the smooth creamy texture is extremely easy to layer and blend. The staying power of the eyeshadow is another highlight that should not go unmentioned as the colors don’t lose any of their brightness throughout the day.

One of the best aspects of these shades is their ability to suit a wide array of occasions and settings. Whether you are at a wedding, a casual hangout with your friends or a late night party, these colors are bound to give you the radiant glow that will have everybody around you talking. Furthermore, the ingredients that were used in the formula are highly safe, so there is no need to worry about any potential skin issues that might stem from a bad reaction to a chemical component.

The pros

  • The eyeshadow palette is very cheap considering its quality
  • The pigmentation of the colors is quite high
  • It does not have any unpleasant smell or strong fragrance
  • The palette can accommodate all skin tones and complexions
  • It blends very easily into the skin
  • It causes no skin irritations or allergic reactions

The cons

  • The glittery shades are not as shiny as advertised
  • Some of the darker pigments have an excessive amount of black fallout

3 - Lamora Best Pro Eyeshadow Palette Makeup

Best Pro Eyeshadow Palette Makeup - Matte Shimmer 16 Colors - Highly Pigmented - Professional Nudes...
9,332 Reviews
Best Pro Eyeshadow Palette Makeup - Matte Shimmer 16 Colors - Highly Pigmented - Professional Nudes...
  • The LAMORA EXPOSED Eyeshadow Palette is inspired by woman´s feminine and gentle side –...
  • A HARMONY OF LUSTROUS HUES in colorful rose gold and royally dark browns for shimmery...
  • PERFECT FOR THE EVERYDAY GIRL, SPECIAL EVENTS or occasions. Use shimmery highlights and...
  • PRO ESSENTIAL MINERAL NATURAL COLOR RANGE with outstanding matte, metallic, satin and...

This palette owes its position in our list to its smooth texture and vivid colors. It offers 16 bright colors that are remarkably pigmented and rich in subtle details. The palette is made from a number of naturally-sourced high-quality ingredients and features a unique ultra-micronized cream formula whose sole purpose is to boost the effectiveness of the shades and improve the staying power on the surface of the skin. The Lamora comes in a sleek case that is geared toward facilitating portability and on-the-go application.

While the number of available shades might seem too low when compared to some other sets at the same price range, it is essential to note that more is not always better. The main focus of the Lamora is to provide the user with every finish imaginable without redundantly repeating a particular color multiple times. As a matter of fact, the 16 colors of this palette cover the full range of the spectrum and you can easily find a shade for every occasion and special event. More importantly, they are extremely effective when it comes to enhancing your features and giving you a natural-looking and long-lasting glow.

The pros

  • The quality to price ratio is very good
  • The level of pigmentation is outstanding
  • It comes in a sleek and compact case that is easy to carry and store
  • The shades are ideal for a wide array of occasions and special events
  • It is made using high-quality organic ingredients and an ultra-micronized cream formula
  • The colors look flawless when used with a primer

The cons

  • It creates a decent amount of fallout from time to time
  • The level of pigmentation is not consistent across all shades

The best eyeshadow palette for blue eyes

Newest trent 5 Colors Make up Eyeshadow Shimmer Eye Highlight Palette

There are several approaches that you can take if you want to emphasize your blue eyes with eyeshadow. One of our favorites is to use something with a similar shade as your eyes, and this palette offers just that. In fact, the Newest Trent features five different shades of blue and boasts a high level of pigmentation that is necessary for making your eyes pop in a natural-looking manner. It is made using a plethora of natural and healthy ingredients such as vanilla powder and it contains no strong chemical components that can irritate the skin. Despite the relatively narrow range of color options, the finishes that are included in the palette are suitable for various occasions and events.

Besides the vivid and highly pigmented shades of blue, one of the defining features of this palette is without a doubt its impressive staying power. Its silky smooth texture settles easily into the skin and can remain consistent for more than 12 hours after the initial application of the eyeshadow. Furthermore, it is waterproof and relatively simple to apply. Its versatility and long-wearing abilities make it suited for both professional and home use.

The pros

  • This is the best eyeshadow palette for blue eyes
  • The colors are highly pigmented
  • It has a silky smooth texture that does not irritate the skin
  • It is long-wearing can stay consistent for more than 12 hours after application
  • The price of the palette is very affordable
  • It is made from organic and healthy ingredients

The cons

  • The inclusion of more color options would have been appreciated
  • The proper application of this eyeshadow requires the use of a brush

The best eyeshadow palette for green eyes

Pro 18 Colors Fashion Eyeshadow Palette Makeup

Pro 18 Colors Fashion Eyeshadow Palette Makeup Highly Pigmented Shimmer and Matte Blendable...
54 Reviews
Pro 18 Colors Fashion Eyeshadow Palette Makeup Highly Pigmented Shimmer and Matte Blendable...
  • Cruelty-free ingredient, made from healthy formula and suitable for everyone's skin.
  • UCANBE 18 Colors Mask Fashion Eyeshadow Palette Left side Roam included 8 matte basic...
  • Fashionable packaging with mirror, easy to carry and but not easy to broken.
  • Super creamy, velvety soft and smooth. It's easy to use and looks great on your eyes. Can...

As it the case with any eye color, there are several options that you can opt for with regard to eyeshadow for green eyes. One of the best is to use varying shades of purple. This is an extremely effective way to draw attention to the pigmentation of the eyes since both colors are naturally complementary. As a consequence, we picked a product that offers exquisite purple colors. This palette features some of the most vivid and pigmented shades of purple that we have encountered on the market. It is made from naturally-sourced ingredients and it is specifically formulated to suit all types of skin.

The texture of this eyeshadow is simply immaculate. It is characterized by a creamy composition and soothing velvet softness. Despite being extremely light, it is remarkably long-lasting, consistent, and not easily broken even after long hours of wearing it. Another great thing about this palette is just how flexible and versatile it is. Aside from the area around the eyes, it can also be applied on top of the lips and even on other parts of the body other than the face, to surprisingly great results.

The pros

  • The creamy texture blends very well and feels soft on the surface of the skin
  • The purple shades are very well pigmented
  • The ingredients used to make it are organic and safe for use by anyone
  • It is extremely flexible and can be applied to other parts of the body
  • The purple undertones naturally complement green eyes and give them a vibrant look
  • The palette offers great value for the money

The cons

  • The packaging is relatively underwhelming and could use a lot of improvement
  • Some of the glittery shades lack a little bit of shine

The best eyeshadow palette for hazel eyes

L'Oréal Paris Infallible Paints Eyeshadow Metallics Violet Luster

There are few colors that can highlight hazel eyes better than a metallic violet shadow. The finish that is offered by this palette boasts the necessary amount of shine and pigmentation to make hazel eyes look more vibrant and vivid. Like all products in our list, the ingredients that make up this formula are entirely organic and safe for use by people who have sensitive skin. Moreover, the neutral properties of the formula make it suited for both oily and dry skin without running the risk of exasperating either condition.

The texture of this metallic finish is another one of its selling points. It is silky smooth and blends evenly into the skin. It is also quite resilient and can be worn for a whole day without requiring an extra round of application.  In addition to all of this, another great quality that this palette has is its ability to offer a decent degree of flexibility with only five shades of purple. This is mostly due to the subtle use of metallic in a way that makes it suited for everyday use as well as at virtually any special event or occasion.

The pros

  • The creamy feel of this palette feels very soothing to the skin
  • The creaseless finish is exquisite and ideal for a wide range of settings
  • It causes no skin irritation
  • The colors are strong and pigmentation is exceptionally high
  • It is long-wearing and seamlessly bendable
  • The price of the palette is tremendous when you consider its high-quality

The cons

  • A few of the shades might be too glittery and shiny for some people
  • The packaging feels cheap and not durable enough

The best eyeshadow palette for brown eye

Maybelline The City Mini Eyeshadow Palette Makeup Matte About Town

Maybelline New York The City Mini Eyeshadow Palette Makeup, Matte About Town, 0.14 oz.
915 Reviews
Maybelline New York The City Mini Eyeshadow Palette Makeup, Matte About Town, 0.14 oz.
  • Creamy formula designed to glide along your eyelid, providing smooth application and...
  • City Mini Eyeshadow Palette and its highly pigmented colors accentuate your eyes to add...
  • Each shimmery and matte eyeshadow palette for eye makeup contains six colors to make a...
  • City Mini Eyeshadow Palette is available in 8 super-saturated shades- from Graffiti Pop...

As far as brown eyes are concerned, we tend to prefer eyeshadow that is relatively close to the color of the eyes, namely burgundy and varying shades of brown. This palette offers a great selection of colors that are rich in detail and pigmentation. The brown shades are especially adept at accentuating your eyes by adding more depth and dimension to them. In addition to this, the palette has a wide range of application and it is the ideal option if you want to create unique custom eye makeup looks.

The creamy formula of this palette is made from premium ingredients and contains no harsh chemicals. As for the texture, it is remarkably soft to the point of gliding along the eyelid in a smooth and effective way.  The eyeshadow blends easily which allows for a decent coverage that lasts for hours after application.

The pros

  • This is one of the most affordable high-quality palettes on the market
  • The burgundy and brown shades boast a very high level of pigmentations
  • The texture is remarkably consistent and blends effectively into the skin
  • The coverage that is provided by this palette is quite decent
  • It is specifically designed to glide effortlessly across the eyelid
  • This palette is the perfect option if you like to create custom and atypical eye makeup looks

The cons

  • The shimmers are somewhat soft and crumbly
  • The use of a primer is necessary if you want to get the most out of this palette

The verdict

When you are not sure what to look for, finding the best eyeshadow palette can become a tedious and lengthy process. Fortunately for you, this guide goes over everything that you need to know in order to make an informed purchase decision. Just take the time to read the reviews multiple times and check what other customers have to say about each product to make sure that you are getting the right option for your needs.

Last update on 2024-04-23 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Copyright © 2024 All Rights Reserved
 This site is a participant in the Amazon services LLC associates program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.